Likewise, Martha J. Haggerty, the second wife of James Old has been found. (see latest documents page, Death Certificates) If you check out the 1860 U.S. Census on James Old & Martha (Haggerty)Old, you will see that some of the Haggerty family are living with James/Martha Old! This was my first clue that Martha J.'s maiden name was Haggerty. It took the death certificates of other family members to confirm it.
I will now change the historical documents to reflect this information.
I have the 1850 U.S. Census on the family of Martha J. Haggerty. Her father was a "grocer", which may be the connection to their marriage. Mary Lee died in April,1850, and this census took place in August, 1850, so the marriage must of taken place after August of 1850. To date I have NOT found their marriage records. It's interesting that Martha J. Haggerty was born in the same year as Mary Lee, 1829 and that in August of 1850 she is 21 years old.
Find this 1850 Census on Martha J. Haggerty on the "Latest Documents" page. The 1860 Census can be found in the "Library" page.